The Second Vatican Council (Vatican II), convened from 1962 to 1965, ushered in significant reforms across the Catholic Church, and its influence reached deep into the heart of monastic communities. While many people are familiar with the changes to the liturgy and Mass, the impact of Vatican II on monastic life itself was profound. It reshaped daily schedules, altered community structures, and brought a new perspective on the spirituality that underpins life in monasteries. Yet, this change was not a wholesale departure from tradition—many communities found ways to balance the Council's call for renewal with their ancient practices.
A New Vision of Community: Abolishing the Two-Class System
Before Vatican II, many monastic communities were structured into a two-class system. There were the choir monks or nuns—often more educated, with a focus on the Divine Office and spiritual study—and the lay brothers or sisters who took on manual labor and simpler tasks, typically praying in the vernacular. The lay members had limited rights within the community; for example, they generally did not have a vote in community elections or in important decisions. Their work was often essential to the running of the monastery, yet they were seen as separate from the full spiritual life of the choir members.
Vatican II, with its emphasis on the universal call to holiness, challenged this separation. It highlighted that every member of a religious community is called to full participation in its spiritual life and mission. This led to the abolition of the two-class system, giving lay brothers and sisters a greater voice and equal standing in the life of the community. They could now participate more fully in the prayer life, spiritual formation, and decision-making processes of the monastery. This change fostered a greater sense of unity and shared purpose, allowing communities to embody the true spirit of monastic fraternity and sorority.
The Habit and the Veil: A Symbol of Change
Another visible change that Vatican II catalyzed within monastic communities was the adaptation of habits, especially the veils worn by nuns. Prior to Vatican II, the veil and habit were often strictly regulated, symbolizing a clear distinction between cloistered life and the outside world. The habit was typically long, covering the nuns from head to toe, including a veil that varied in length and design depending on the order.
Vatican II encouraged religious communities to simplify their habits, allowing for a return to the original spirit of their founders and emphasizing the habit's role as a sign of consecration, rather than as a symbol of separation from society. This meant that many communities opted for simpler, more practical attire that still served as a sign of their vocation but allowed for greater mobility and comfort in daily life and work.
The change in the veil was perhaps the most visible of these adjustments. While some communities chose to keep the traditional long veils, others adopted shorter or simpler versions. This shift allowed for a greater sense of openness and engagement with the world, reflecting the Council’s desire for religious life to be more accessible and less focused on external distinctions. It symbolized a deeper focus on inner transformation and spiritual dedication, rather than external appearances.
Latin vs. Vernacular: A Balance of Tradition and Accessibility
One of the most noticed changes in the Church post-Vatican II was the shift from Latin to the vernacular in liturgical celebrations. This made the liturgy more accessible to the faithful, allowing them to engage more deeply with the words of the Mass and the Divine Office. Many monasteries embraced this change, finding that praying in their native language allowed both monks and visitors to connect with the prayers on a more personal level.
However, not all monastic communities chose to give up Latin entirely. Some continued to value the use of Latin for their psalms, hymns, and chants, seeing it as a way to maintain a connection with the universal Church. Praying in Latin preserved a sense of continuity with the centuries-old traditions of monastic life and the rich heritage of the Church’s liturgical language. For these communities, the use of Latin is a way to remember that their prayer life is part of something much larger—the global communion of the Church that transcends time and place.
This balance—embracing the vernacular while still valuing the Latin roots—is emblematic of how many monastic communities navigated the changes of Vatican II. They adapted to the modern world while holding onto the elements that connect them to their ancient spiritual lineage.
A Shift in the Rhythm: Aligning the Liturgy of the Hours
Vatican II also emphasized the importance of celebrating the Liturgy of the Hours at times that correspond to the natural rhythms of the day. Before the Council, the timing of the Divine Office could sometimes seem unusual to contemporary sensibilities—Lauds, for example, might be prayed at 2 PM, far removed from its original intent as a morning prayer.
The Council encouraged monastic communities to restore the traditional timing of the hours, ensuring that Morning Prayer was offered in the morning, Evening Prayer at sunset, and Night Prayer before bed. This adjustment helped reconnect the daily rhythm of monastic prayer with the natural flow of the day, bringing a renewed sense of harmony between the liturgical rhythm and the physical world.
For the monks and nuns, this shift brought a deeper experience of prayer, as the times of the day and their prayers became more intimately connected. It also allowed them to pray in union with the broader Church, knowing that their morning prayer was being said at the same time as other communities around the world.
Praying the Psalms: A Change in the Cycle
Another significant change was the adjustment in the cycle of psalmody. Before Vatican II, many monastic communities followed a weekly cycle in which they would pray through all 150 psalms within seven days. This demanding schedule was a hallmark of traditional monastic life and provided a deep immersion in the psalter. However, it also required a significant time commitment that was challenging to maintain, especially for communities with apostolic work or a smaller number of members.
Vatican II allowed for greater flexibility, making it possible to spread the psalms over a longer period, such as two weeks or even four weeks and abolished the prayer of the Prime. This adjustment enabled monastic communities to maintain a rich prayer life while also adapting to the realities of modern life. It allowed more time for personal reflection, study, and engagement with guests, without sacrificing the heart of the psalm-based prayer tradition.
Breaking Down Barriers: The Removal of Grilles in Monasteries
Another notable change following Vatican II was the removal or disuse of grilles in many women’s monasteries. Traditionally, these grilles were used in chapels, visitation rooms, and other areas as a physical barrier between the cloistered nuns and the outside world, emphasizing their separation and commitment to a hidden life. However, the Council's emphasis on openness and greater connection with the broader Church community led many monasteries to reconsider their use. As a result, grilles were often removed or simply no longer utilized, fostering a sense of greater closeness between the sisters and those who visit. This change allowed for more personal encounters while still respecting the unique contemplative vocation of the monastic life.
Embracing the New While Honoring the Old
Vatican II’s reforms to monastic life brought many changes, but they were not about discarding the past. Rather, the Council invited monastic communities to re-examine their practices, to renew what was essential, and to adapt what was no longer necessary in a modern context. For many, this has meant living a dynamic balance between the old and the new—honoring centuries of tradition while being open to the Holy Spirit's guidance in a changing world.
Monasteries today remain places of prayer, silence, and community, but they are also welcoming spaces where people from the outside world can come to learn, pray, and experience the richness of monastic spirituality. The spirit of Vatican II continues to inspire this adaptation and renewal, ensuring that monastic life remains a vibrant witness to the timeless call to seek God in every age.
The Legacy of Vatican II in Monastic Life
For those who seek a monastic vocation today, the changes brought about by Vatican II have made monasteries places of deep continuity and gentle renewal. Monastic life remains a path of transformation, grounded in ancient traditions but alive with the spirit of the present. The reforms of Vatican II have opened the doors of monasteries to the world, inviting a new generation to discover the treasures of prayer, community, and contemplation. At the same time, they remind us that the journey to God is one that requires both faithfulness to the past and openness to the new ways in which He is speaking today.
Comments